The Power of a Book Cover

Are We Valuing Aesthetics Over Literary Merit?

We’ve all done it: judged a book by its cover. It’s hard not to when we’re surrounded by choice, especially in an age where Instagram grids and TikTok hauls shape what we read. A gorgeous cover can catch our eye, pique our interest, and make us assume the story inside is just as captivating. But what about the books that don’t get that same design love? Are we overlooking great stories just because they don’t look the part?

I’m as guilty as anyone. I picked up Vengeance of the Pirate Queen by Tricia Levenseller entirely because of the illustrated, swashbuckling cover and the word “pirate.” I found a different edition later—with a completely different cover—and honestly, if I’d seen that version first, I might have passed it by. It wasn’t an ugly cover by any means; it just didn’t match what I’m instinctively drawn to. (For me, illustrated covers > photographic ones. Every time.)

This got me thinking: how much are our reading habits influenced by design—and are we valuing aesthetics over literary merit?

Covers as Gatekeepers

Covers have always served a purpose: to grab attention, give clues about genre, and appeal to the right readers. A dark, minimalist design might signal literary fiction or psychological suspense; a pastel colour palette and bold font might scream romance or slice-of-life. But when design trends take over, something strange happens: covers start to look the same.

Scroll through a list of popular new releases and you’ll likely see patterns—lots of objects in symmetrical layouts, lots of serif fonts, lots of illustrated women with no faces. These trends can help books fit the market, but they can also flatten individuality. Worse, they might confuse readers if the cover doesn’t clearly reflect the book’s tone or genre. A rom-com-style cover on a fantasy novel can set up the wrong expectations entirely.

I sometimes look at my older YA books with their black, minimalist covers and realise that while I still love the stories inside, the covers no longer speak to me—or to what I’d want to share online. It’s a strange feeling when a favourite book no longer looks like something I’d pick up today. Maybe that’s part of the reason rebranding is so tempting for publishers—and why it’s so effective.

The Endless Rebranding Cycle

Rebranding older books to match current trends is nothing new, but it feels more aggressive than ever. A book that once had a moody, ornate cover might now be re-released with something slick, minimal, and TikTok-friendly. Jane Austen alone has had more wardrobe changes than Barbie.

Sometimes this works, helping a brilliant story reach a new generation of readers. Other times, it can feel disingenuous—like slapping a new cover on a book and hoping people won’t notice it’s ten years old. And for longtime fans, it can be a bit jarring to see a beloved book’s personality rewritten.

And don’t even get me started on series that switch cover styles halfway through. One minute you’ve got three matching paperbacks lined up on your shelf, and then book four shows up dressed for a completely different party. Suddenly your nice tidy row is a crime against aesthetics—and yes, it’s petty, but it hurts.

It’s Not the Author’s Fault

It’s important to remember that most authors don’t have much (if any) say in what their book looks like. Cover design is usually handled by a publishing team, with marketing and trend forecasts guiding the final decision. That can be tough when the book someone poured their heart into ends up packaged in a way that doesn’t quite fit—or worse, makes it disappear on the shelf.

What Can We Do as Readers?

We’re all visual creatures, and there’s no shame in being drawn to a beautiful book. But it’s worth asking ourselves: What are we missing when we judge a book by its cover alone?

Here are a few ways to look past the surface:

• Read the first page. A well-written hook can say more than a pretty spine.
• Check reviews from readers you trust. Especially those who read widely or share your tastes.
• Try cover-blind browsing. Some indie bookstores (and even libraries) offer wrapped books with just a short description. It’s a fun way to challenge your instincts.
• Follow small publishers and indie authors. Their covers may not always be trend-driven, but they often house fresh, exciting voices.

Final Thoughts

Covers matter. They always have, and in the age of Bookstagram and BookTok, their influence is stronger than ever. But if we let them completely shape our choices, we risk missing out on books that don’t conform to the current aesthetic but are just as worthy of our time.

So next time a plain or off-trend cover makes you hesitate, take a moment. Read the blurb. Crack open the first chapter. You might just discover a new favourite hiding in plain sight.

💡 Love discussions like this? Explore more of our book discussion articles.